Sweet Tomatoes Pizza in Chatham, MA, is a beloved gem in the pizza scene. Customers rave about the variety and quality of their offerings, including specialty pizzas like the Chicken & Broccoli and the unique Clam Casino Pizza, which delight the palate with their robust flavors. The restaurant's commitment to using fresh ingredients shines through in their salads, such as the refreshing Caprese served over focaccia bread, and their customizable pizza options, allowing patrons to explore creative toppings like artichokes and eggplant. The ambiance is warm and welcoming, with guests highlighting the friendly service that enhances the dining experience. Many have enjoyed outdoor dining with their pets, a testament to the family-run atmosphere that Sweet Tomatoes fosters. Such hospitality is often mentioned alongside the delicious food, creating a blend of comfort and joy that keeps visitors returning. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, Sweet Tomatoes promises a satisfying meal, from hearty pizzas to fresh salads and sandwiches. With positive feedback on service and food quality, including generous portion sizes, it's clear that Sweet Tomatoes Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving a fulfilling and delightful meal in Chatham.
Amenities and More
Service options
Has outdoor seating
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Offerings
Serves alcohol
Serves beer
Dining options
Serves lunch
Has seating
Payments
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Photos
Reviews For Sweet Tomatoes Pizza
Hailee Paquette
May 27,2025
We went twice over MDW and the service and staff were wonderful, we ate outside with our golden retriever, the staff came and said hi to him! The food was great! Pizza was excellent.
jim capone
May 22,2025
Ordered a large cheese pizza with peppers and mushrooms. Also a Chicken Parmesan sub. Both were very big and really good! The man at the register was very nice and ran my order out to my car when it was ready. I would highly recommend this restaurant if you’re new to the area/vacationing and want a nice hot, easy meal to take back to your rental or hotel.
Surjeet Mishra
May 12,2025
Lovely family run pizzeria. Great options at decent price. Try the speciality pizza or create your own with specialty toppings artichoke, eggplant and many more. Amazing hospitality. 5 star all around. Must visit if you are in Chatham or Provincetown, MA.
Kelly Aitchison
Apr 18,2025
My family and I have been ordering from this establishment for years now and absolutely love their pizza, wings, and fries. The staff is always very friendly and the food is great too!!!
Kelsey Morse
Mar 20,2025
I truly appreciate the team at Sweet Tomatoes. Excuse me if I am butchering the spelling but Merrill is so dedicated and it shows in the quality of their food and of their service. Top notch people who work so hard and perform so well under a lot of pressure in a hot kitchen. Tourists should give these folks some grace, love you guys you are the best of the best and you deserve a ton of success. Keep it up.
Susan Mandeville
Feb 27,2025
First time here for the three of us.counter service. The guy at the counter very friendly and helpful. We ordered a large 3 topping pizza sausage,pepperoni and mushrooms.it was delivered to our table fresh,hot and delicious.all three of us said “best pizza we’ve had in cape cod! We will be back.
Carol Ann Jason
Feb 24,2025
Sweet Tomatoes Pizza is the place to go for salad and pizza. We had a delicious goat cheese salad with caramelized onions, field greens, bacon, and raspberry dressing. The Margarita pizza was the best we have every tasted. The crust was thin and crispy without being overcooked, and the tomatoes and basil were so tasty. Order and pay at the counter and the food is delivered to your table. One may eat inside or at outdoor tables in front.
Corey Robert
Feb 23,2025
Was visiting on vacation and stopped in Chatham for the day. Everyone was craving pizza, and came across Sweet Tomatoes. I unfortunately called the Yarmouth location so when I got there they of course didn't have the order. Felt like an idiot but they assured me it was okay and it happens. Glad we chose here as the pizza was unbelievable. The undercarriage was charred up perfectly, when finished eating we all looked like we worked in the coal mine, which is an absolute compliment if you know good pizza. I forget the gentleman's name who came out to see how the pizza was and say hi to our dog but kudos to him Fantastic all around. Dave Portnoy would be doing himself a favor by coming here.
Reviews For Sweet Tomatoes Pizza